Deal rating · How this works
A rating for the price, worked out from the record.
Beside some prices you will see Weak, Fair, Good or Great. It is not a review and nobody chose it. It is the answer to one question, worked out by the same rules for every product and every brand: against everything we have recorded for this exact product, is this a good price?
1 · The four ratings, and what each one promises
The sentence under each rating is the one you see on the product page
Among the lowest prices we have tracked for this machine.
If you want it, this is the time.
Earned by The price is within 5% of the lowest we have recorded for this product, and it is either a new low or at least 10% under what the product usually sells for. We also need at least 90 days of price record before we will say this.
A genuine saving, better than the price this machine usually sells for.
Earned by The price is clearly below what this product usually sells for, judged on its own past sale prices or, with too few of those, on the price it normally shows.
A fair discount, but around the usual discount for this machine.
Earned by A real discount, but nothing in the record says it is better than this product's usual discount. This is also where a deal lands when the sale itself is strong but misses another requirement, such as how long we have tracked the product or how many similar sales it has had recently.
Little effectively saved. Either the cut is too small to matter or the list price was raised before this sale.
Earned by Either the saving is too small to matter (under 5% or under 10 in the currency of the price), or the list price was raised before the sale so the discount only brings it back.
2 · What the price is compared against
The percentage off list price never lifts a rating on its own
01
This product's own prices, in this currency
Every rating compares a price with the record of that same product in that same currency. A product is never judged by another, not even a sibling model from the same brand.
02
What it usually sells for
The price it has most often gone on sale at before, when it has had enough sales to call that a habit. Otherwise the middle of the prices we recorded before this sale opened. The list price is not this number.
03
The lowest price before this sale
Great means the price is among the lowest we have ever seen for this product, so there has to be an earlier price to beat. A product that has been on the same sale since before we started tracking it has no earlier price yet, so it cannot be Great until the record catches up.
04
How often it is discounted
A product that was discounted more than 40% of the time in the months before this sale is not on a special offer, the discounted price is simply its price. The rating is held at Fair whatever the percentage off list says, unless this sale is a clear new low for the product.
05
Repeats and long sales
Repetition lowers the rating. The same sale price coming back again and again is a routine, not an opportunity, so a sale we have seen recently is held at Good and one we have seen several times in a year is held at Fair. A sale that simply runs on for months comes down a step at a time too, because by then the sale price is the price.
06
Whether the list price moved
The percentage off list is the brand's claim about itself, and a brand can raise its list price the week before a sale. We keep a record of list price changes, and a sale that only undoes a raise is marked Weak.
3 · When you see no rating at all
A missing rating is a feature, not a gap in data. When the record is too thin to support any of the four ratings, we are not confident enough to say whether a deal is good or not. The price, the list price and the price history are still there for you to judge yourself.
- Fewer than 60 days of recorded prices for this product in this currency.
- No price or no list price to compare, for example a code-only offer where the store price is unchanged.
- A product that has been retired or replaced.
4 · What the rating is not
Not an opinion.
I don't pick the rating. The same rules run across every deal on 3dp.sale.
Not for sale.
No brand or store can pay for a rating, and the commission a link may earn plays no part in it.
Not a review.
It says whether the price is good against this product's own record. It says nothing about whether the product is the right one for you.
Not fixed.
The record grows and the rating follows it. A Great today can become Good and then Fair if the sale runs on for months, because by then the sale price is the price.
Questions
See also
About this page
The numbers on this page are read from the same code that produces the ratings, so they are always the rules in force today.